Welcome to Bodkin Scholar
Bodkin Scholar is where the core knowledge of Bodkin lies; an autonomous AI librarian who meticulously tends to the Bodkin corpus. Searching for updates, shifts in law and honing legal answers based off user feedback. Scholar is free to search.
- General deterrence and children
General deterrence, which aims to discourage other people from offending, is excluded when a child is sentenced under the Youth Justice Act 2024, but still counts, in a reduced way, when an adult is sentenced for an offence committed as a child.
- Youth control orders
A youth control order is an alternative to detention for a child whose serious or habitual offending would otherwise lead to custody; it needs an imprisonable offence, the child's consent, suitability and a youth justice plan, carries conditions, and lasts up…
- Detaining a child under 14
A child who was under 14 at the time of the offence cannot be sentenced to detention unless the offence is a listed serious one and the court finds a serious risk to community safety; a parallel bar applies in adult courts.
- Sentencing children
In Victoria's Children's Court, children are sentenced under the Youth Justice Act 2024 rather than the adult regime: rehabilitation gets the highest priority, general deterrence does not apply, orders follow a hierarchy with minimum intervention, and…
- Complicity
How Victorian law holds a person liable for an offence someone else commits: what counts as being involved (assisting, encouraging, directing or agreeing), what the prosecution must prove, how courts treat presence at the scene, withdrawal, and the 2014…
- General deterrence
What general deterrence means in Victorian sentencing, where it comes from in the Sentencing Act 1991, when courts give it more or less weight (including for young offenders and offenders with a mental impairment), and how the law has changed.
- SentencingAbsence of Criminal History — R v Uluivuya [2025] VSC 29
This case concerns the sentencing of Edward Uluivuya, aged 55, who pleaded guilty to intentionally causing serious injury to Ropate Raqauqau in circumstances of gross violence.
- SentencingDelay — Tones v The Queen [2017] VSCA 118
This is an appeal against sentence brought by David Tones, who was convicted by a jury of 12 charges of sexual offending against two teenage girls.
- Unlawful assaultMens Rea (cf: stalking)
Unlawful assault in Victoria requires proof of both a physical act (actus reus) and a fault element (mens rea).
- BailRight to Associate with Family
This analysis concerns the legal framework governing bail conditions that restrict an accused person's right to associate with family members, including siblings and cousins.