Youth control orders

Bodkin·9 Nov 2026

A youth control order is an alternative to detention for a child whose serious or habitual offending would otherwise lead to custody; it needs an imprisonable offence, the child's consent, suitability and a youth justice plan, carries conditions, and lasts up to twelve months.

A youth control order is an order the Children's Court may make for a child found guilty of one or more offences where the child would otherwise be sentenced to detention in a youth justice custodial centre because of the gravity or habitual nature of the child's unlawful behaviour.1 It operates within a youth justice scheme in which any deprivation of liberty is a last resort and for the minimum period appropriate.2 The order is available only if the offence, or one of the offences, is punishable by imprisonment, the Court has made inquiries of the Secretary and is satisfied the child is suitable, the child consents, and a youth justice plan has been developed.3 The Children's Court must order a youth justice planning meeting if it is considering making the order.4 The order carries core conditions and may carry developmental, restrictive and restorative conditions.56 Contravention by a parent and contravention by a child are treated differently: the Court must take no action on a parent's undertaking, while the Secretary may apply to vary or revoke the order for the child's alleged contravention.78

General information about Victorian criminal law, not legal advice. Built from Bodkin's research answers and checked claim by claim against the judgments and the Acts in force on 9 November 2026.

The rule

The guiding youth justice principle in s 19(a) of the Youth Justice Act 2024 (Vic) is that any deprivation of liberty is to be a last resort and for the minimum period appropriate.9

The Children's Court may make a youth control order if it finds the child guilty of one or more offences and considers that the child would otherwise be sentenced to detention in a youth justice custodial centre as a result of the gravity or habitual nature of the child's unlawful behaviour.10

The Children's Court must not make a youth control order unless the offence, or one of the offences, committed by the child is punishable by imprisonment,11 the Court has made inquiries of the Secretary and is satisfied that the child is a suitable person to be placed on a youth control order,12 the child consents to a youth control order being made,13 and a youth justice plan has been developed for the child.14

A youth justice plan is a plan that, among other things, provides the Children's Court with information about which special conditions would best meet the objects of a youth supervision and support order or a youth control order (as the case requires).15 The Children's Court must order a youth justice planning meeting if it is considering making a youth control order for the child.16 A youth justice plan must be agreed to by the child.17

A youth control order must not exceed 12 months and must not extend beyond the child's twenty-first birthday.1819

When sentencing a child for an indictable offence, the Supreme Court or County Court may impose any sentence the Children's Court may impose under the Act, but an order that the child be detained in a youth justice custodial centre must be made in accordance with Subdivision (4) of Division 2 of Part 3 of the Sentencing Act 1991.2021

The Act expressly provides for a youth control order made by a court other than the Children's Court, with monitoring, variation and revocation matters remitted to the Children's Court unless that court considers it inappropriate.22

A custodial order carries recording and reasons requirements: the Court must record a conviction, state in writing the reasons for the order, cause the statement to be entered in the court register, and, unless the Court otherwise orders, cause a copy to be provided to the child, the child's parents and any other parties within 21 days, and, if the child is an Aboriginal child, provide reasons outlining how it has had regard to the sentencing principles in s 210.23

Under the former Act, the same four conditions already applied before a youth control order could be made, including inquiries of the Secretary, the child's consent and a plan.24 Under the former Act, the Court already had to have regard to a list of matters, including bail supervision behaviour and acknowledgment of responsibility, in deciding whether to make a youth control order.25

Part 5.3 of Chapter 5 of the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic) was repealed by the Youth Justice Act 2024 (Vic), but, subject to the Act's transitional provisions, a person already subject to an order made under it continues to be subject to the requirements of that order, and Part 5.3 continues to apply to that order as if it had not been repealed.26

How courts apply it

A youth justice custodial order may be made by the Children's Court only if it is satisfied that a youth control order is inappropriate in the circumstances.27

In determining whether to make a youth control order, the Children's Court must have regard to each of the factors in s 280(3), including the youth justice planning meeting report, any pre-sentence report, any previous pre-sentence report and supplementary pre-sentence report, and any other matter the court considers relevant.2829

The core conditions in s 283(1) require the child not to commit an offence punishable by imprisonment, whether in or outside Victoria, during the period of the order; to report to the Secretary within 2 working days after the order is made; to comply with any lawful and reasonable directions given by the Secretary; to report to the Secretary as and when required during the order; to attend the Children's Court as directed under s 294; to participate in education, training or work, whether paid or unpaid, for some or all of the period of the order; to notify the Secretary of any change in residence, school or employment within 2 working days; and not to leave Victoria without the permission of the Secretary.30

The core conditions in s 283(1) apply to every youth control order, and the court may also attach one or more developmental conditions, one or more restrictive conditions and the restorative condition.31

Under s 32(1) of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic), as substituted by the Youth Justice Act 2024 and subject to subsections (2C), (2D) and (2E), a court may make a youth justice custodial order for a young offender if a sentence involving confinement is justified, it has received a pre-sentence report and believes there are reasonable prospects for the young offender's rehabilitation or that the young offender is particularly impressionable, immature or likely to be subjected to undesirable influences in an adult prison, and it has had regard to the matters in s 32(2).32

At common law, the Court of Appeal in Gosland v R observed that a Youth Justice Centre Order is inherently less onerous than a sentence of imprisonment to be served in an adult prison, and that the order made in that case reflected the premium which the judge placed on rehabilitation.33

In Bower v R, Macaulay JA noted that, under the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) as it stood when the case was decided, a youth justice centre order is described in the Act as "confinement" and "detention" and "it is not a term of imprisonment".34

The objects of a youth control order include allowing the child to participate in community and family life in a judicially supervised and intensively supported way,35 providing intensive, targeted supervision to help the child develop an ability to abide by the law,36 and giving the child an opportunity to demonstrate a desire to cease offending.37

Limits and exceptions

The Children's Court cannot impose a sentence of detention on a child who was under 14 years of age at the time of the offence unless the offence is a Category A serious youth offence, a Category B serious youth offence or any other offence against a person that the Court considers to be serious and violent, and the Court is reasonably satisfied that the child presents a serious risk to community safety.38

If an undertaking given under section 285 is contravened, the Children's Court must not take any action.3940 The parent's undertaking is to "support the child to comply with the youth control order".41

Form 13A of the Children's Court Criminal Procedure Rules 2019 (Vic), a form that refers to section 409B of the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic), has the parent state: "I [name] undertake to support the child to comply with this youth control order for [period] until [end date]."42 It provides for conditions to be inserted and for the parent's acknowledgment, orally or by signature.43

Under the former Act, s 409H provided that if an undertaking under s 409G was breached, the Court must not take any action.4445

When the child, not the parent, is alleged to have contravened a youth control order, the Secretary may apply to the Children's Court to vary or revoke it.46 Where a child is found to have contravened a youth control order, the Court may revoke it and make any order it could have made for the offence in the first place,47 but it may not impose a sentence higher in the s 240(1) hierarchy than the youth control order unless the child commits an offence punishable on first conviction with imprisonment for 5 years or more during the order, or the order's conditions or the support offered cannot be varied in a way that would make the order suitable for the child.48 The Secretary must prepare a contravention report on the child when an application is made or a notice to appear is served over an alleged contravention of the order.49

Footnotes

  1. 1 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 280(1).
  2. 2 Ibid s 19(a).
  3. 3 Ibid s 280(2).
  4. 4 Ibid s 282(1).
  5. 5 Ibid s 283(1).
  6. 6 Ibid s 283(2).
  7. 7 Ibid s 286.
  8. 8 Ibid s 307(3).
  9. 9 Ibid s 19(a).
  10. 10 Ibid s 280(1).
  11. 11 Ibid s 280(2)(a).
  12. 12 Ibid s 280(2)(b).
  13. 13 Ibid s 280(2)(c).
  14. 14 Ibid s 280(2).
  15. 15 Ibid s 288(1).
  16. 16 Ibid s 282(1).
  17. 17 Ibid s 288(2).
  18. 18 Ibid s 284.
  19. 19 Ibid s 284.
  20. 20 Ibid s 241(1).
  21. 21 Ibid s 241(1).
  22. 22 Ibid s 287.
  23. 23 Ibid s 325(3).
  24. 24 Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic) s 409C.
  25. 25 Ibid s 409E.
  26. 26 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 872.
  27. 27 Ibid s 240(1)(h).
  28. 28 Ibid s 280(3).
  29. 29 Ibid s 280(3).
  30. 30 Ibid s 283(1).
  31. 31 Ibid s 283(2).
  32. 32 Ibid s 1128(2).
  33. 33 Gosland v The Queen [2013] VSCA 269, [30].
  34. 34 Bower v The King [2024] VSCA 317, [41].
  35. 35 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 281.
  36. 36 Ibid s 281(d).
  37. 37 Ibid s 281(f).
  38. 38 Ibid s 324.
  39. 39 Ibid s 286.
  40. 40 Ibid s 286.
  41. 41 Ibid s 285(1).
  42. 42 Children's Court Criminal Procedure Rules 2019 Form 13A.
  43. 43 Ibid.
  44. 44 Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic) s 409H.
  45. 45 Ibid s 409H (, historic).
  46. 46 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 307(3).
  47. 47 Ibid s 309(1)(c).
  48. 48 Ibid s 309(4).
  49. 49 Ibid s 428(1).

Request access, or sign in.