A child who was under 14 at the time of the offence cannot be sentenced to detention unless the offence is a listed serious one and the court finds a serious risk to community safety; a parallel bar applies in adult courts.
The Children's Court must not impose a sentence of detention on a child who was under 14 when the offence was committed unless the offence falls within a listed category and the Court is reasonably satisfied that the child presents a serious risk to community safety.12 That bar is in s 324 of the Youth Justice Act 2024 (Vic), and the Court's power to order detention under s 325(1) is expressly subject to it.3 A parallel bar in s 32AA of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) applies to a court and so reaches young offenders sentenced outside the Children's Court.45 The two provisions also differ in how strong the risk finding must be: s 324 requires the Court to be reasonably satisfied, whereas s 32AA(2)(b) asks whether the Court considers that the young offender presents a serious risk to community safety.67
General information about Victorian criminal law, not legal advice. Built from Bodkin's research answers and checked claim by claim against the judgments and the Acts in force on 9 November 2026.
The rule
Section 324 of the Youth Justice Act 2024 (Vic) provides that the Children's Court must not impose a sentence of detention on a child who it finds guilty of an offence if, at the time the offence was committed, the child was under 14 years of age unless the conditions in the section are met.8 The note to s 208 states that s 324 prevents the Children's Court from imposing a sentence of detention on a child who was under 14 years of age at the time of the offending unless the offence is a Category A serious youth offence, a Category B serious youth offence or any other offence the Court considers to be a serious and violent offence, and the Court is reasonably satisfied that the child presents a serious risk to community safety.9
The Children's Court's power to order that a child be detained in a youth justice custodial centre is in s 325(1), which is expressly subject to s 324.10
Section 208 states the sentencing principle that a sentence imposed on a child should be the minimum intervention required in the circumstances.11 The guiding youth justice principle in s 19(a) is that any deprivation of liberty be a last resort and for the minimum period appropriate.12
A child is a person who is under 18 years of age.13 A child also includes a person who was under 18 at the time of the offence, unless excluded by s 4(3).14 A child who was under 14 when the offence was committed is within the protection of s 324 even if older when sentenced, unless excluded because they were 19 years of age or over when the proceeding for the offence was commenced.15
Section 32AA(1) of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic), as in force in version 234 from 30 September 2026, provides that a court must not impose a sentence of detention on a young offender who it finds guilty of an offence if, at the time the offence was committed, the young offender was under 14 years of age.16 Under s 32AA(2) the bar can be lifted if the offence is a Category A or Category B serious youth offence, or another offence against the person the court considers serious and violent, and the court considers the young offender presents a serious risk to community safety.17
Section 32 of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) lets a court, where a sentence involving confinement is justified in respect of a young offender, make a youth justice custodial order if the conditions in s 32(1) are met.18 The period of detention may not exceed two years in the Magistrates' Court or four years in the County Court or the Supreme Court.19 Under s 32(1) the court must have received a pre-sentence report and believe either that there are reasonable prospects for the rehabilitation of the young offender or that the young offender is particularly impressionable, immature or likely to be subjected to undesirable influences in an adult prison, and it must have had regard to the matters in subsection (2).20
The Act defines Category A serious youth offences by a list that begins with murder, attempted murder, manslaughter, child homicide and homicide by firearm.21 A Category B serious youth offence is defined by a list of Crimes Act 1958 sections that includes rape and home invasion.22
How courts apply it
Passing s 324 does not entitle the court to impose detention: the power to order that a child be detained in a youth justice custodial centre is subject to s 324 and to the further requirements in s 325(2).23 Before making a youth justice custodial order the Children's Court must be satisfied that the circumstances and nature of the offence are sufficiently serious to warrant the order and that no other sentence is appropriate.24 When the Children's Court makes a youth justice custodial order it must state in writing the reasons for the order.25
In sentencing a child, a court is not to take into account the guiding youth justice principles.26
Section 202(3) provides that the common law principle of general deterrence does not apply to the sentencing of a child under the Youth Justice Act 2024.27 In Eade v R, decided under the Sentencing Act 1991 rather than the Youth Justice Act 2024, the Court of Appeal approved the Director's concession that general deterrence, while not excluded altogether when a young offender is sentenced under the Sentencing Act 1991, can only rarely be used to increase a sentence materially.2829 In C N K v The Queen, decided under the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic), the Court of Appeal held that the statutory language conveyed, as a matter of necessary implication, a clear legislative intention to exclude general deterrence from the sentencing of a young offender.30
In Woods v DPP, a bail decision under the Bail Act 1977 as it then stood, the Court said that the detention of young people on remand can have deleterious consequences for them and the community.31 In Re TS, a bail decision, the Court said that, as the Act mandates, the remand of a child is a course of last resort, and that every possible step that can reasonably be taken to avoid the detrimental effects of the detention of a child should be taken.32 In Re SL, a bail decision, the Court listed among the matters a bail decision-maker must take into account for a child "the presumption at common law that a child who is 10 years of age or over but under 14 years of age cannot commit an offence".33
In Rootsey v The Queen the Court of Appeal set out, as the proper approach, what Nettle JA said in Boland: where offences committed while an offender is a child or immature are not prosecuted until many years after the event, there is good reason to mitigate penalty, or at least to do so where the offender has achieved a significant degree of rehabilitation and there has been no further offending; and although such an offender falls to be sentenced as an adult, the assessment of the nature and gravity of the crime and of the offender's moral culpability take into account that what was done was done as a child.34 The Court of Appeal has found no compelling reason to alter the current sentencing approach to adults being sentenced for childhood offences.35 The approach taken is to moderate appropriately the penalty imposed on an adult guilty of a childhood offence.36 In sentencing an adult for a childhood offence, the weight given to deterrence is reduced to reflect the immaturity of the offender at the time of the offence, although deterrence (including general deterrence) continues to have relevance.37 Denunciation can likewise be diminished to reflect the offender's immaturity.38
Limits and exceptions
Section 324 is directed expressly to the Children's Court.39 Section 32AA of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) applies to a court generally, but the Sentencing Act applies to all courts except the Children's Court.40 Section 324 requires the Court to be "reasonably satisfied" that the child presents a serious risk to community safety, whereas s 32AA(2)(b) asks only whether "the Court considers" that the young offender presents that risk.41
Where the Supreme Court or the County Court sentences a child for an indictable offence, an order that the child be detained in a youth justice custodial centre must be made in accordance with Subdivision (4) of Division 2 of Part 3 of the Sentencing Act 1991.42 That Subdivision includes s 32AA.43
A person who was under 14 at the time of the offence, and who was 19 or over when the proceeding for the offence began, is no longer within the youth justice definition of child and falls to be sentenced under the Sentencing Act 1991.44
In the Sentencing Act 1991 a young offender is an offender who is under 21 when sentenced, so the youth custodial order provisions and s 32AA reach some adults sentenced in adult courts.45
Under s 32(2C) a court must not make a youth justice custodial order for a young offender sentenced for a category A serious youth offence unless it is satisfied that exceptional circumstances exist.46 Section 32(2D) applies the same bar to a category B serious youth offence only where the young offender has previously been convicted of a category A or category B serious youth offence.47 Both exclude a young offender who is a child within the meaning of the Youth Justice Act 2024.48
Footnotes
- 1 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 324.
- 2 Ibid s 208.
- 3 Ibid s 325(1).
- 4 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 32AA.
- 5 Ibid s 32AA.
- 6 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 324.
- 7 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 32AA.
- 8 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 324.
- 9 Ibid s 208.
- 10 Ibid s 325(1).
- 11 Ibid s 208.
- 12 Ibid s 19.
- 13 Ibid s 4.
- 14 Ibid s 4.
- 15 Ibid s 4.
- 16 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 32AA.
- 17 Ibid s 32AA.
- 18 Ibid s 32.
- 19 Ibid s 32.
- 20 Ibid s 32(1).
- 21 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 3.
- 22 Ibid s 3.
- 23 Ibid s 325(1).
- 24 Ibid s 325(2)(c).
- 25 Ibid s 325(3)(b).
- 26 Ibid s 17(2).
- 27 Ibid s 202(3).
- 28 Ibid s 202(3).
- 29 Eade v The Queen [2012] VSCA 142, [42].
- 30 Ibid [42].
- 31 Woods v DPP [2014] VSC 1, [95].
- 32 Re TS [2024] VSC 164, [32].
- 33 Re SL [2025] VSC 571, [27].
- 34 Rootsey v The Queen [2018] VSCA 108, [12].
- 35 Pamic v The King [2026] VSCA 173, [51].
- 36 Ibid [45].
- 37 Ibid [45].
- 38 Ibid [46].
- 39 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 324.
- 40 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 4.
- 41 Youth Justice Act 2024 s 324.
- 42 Ibid s 241(1).
- 43 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 32AA.
- 44 Pamic (n 35) [38].
- 45 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 3.
- 46 Ibid s 32(2C).
- 47 Ibid s 32(2D).
- 48 Ibid s 32(2D).